ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Aerobic exercise training for migraine prevention: A trigger-based analysis


Treinamento físico aeróbico na prevenção da migrânea: Uma análise de fatores desencadeantes

Arão Belitardo Oliveira(1,2)
Diego Belandrino Swerts(3)
Mario Fernando Prieto Peres(1,3)
1- Universidade de São Paulo, Instituto de Psiquiatria, Hospital das Clínicas da Faculdade de Medicina, 785, Rua Dr. Ovídio Pires de Campos, CEP: 05403-903, São Paulo - SP, Brazil.
2- Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Departamento de Neurologia e Neurocirurgia, 669, Pedro de Toledo, CEP 04039-032 São Paulo, Brazil.
3- Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, Brain Institute, 627/701, Avenida Albert Einstein, CEP 05652-900, São Paulo, Brazil.

*Correspondence

Arão Belitardo Oliveira

E-mail: araoliva@gmail.com; aboliveira@ unifesp.br

Received: February 15, 2019.

Accepted: February 25, 2019.

DOI: 10.5935/2178-7468.20190018

ABSTRACT

Background: Although aerobic exercise has been recommended for migraine management, no study has yet explored the effects of regular aerobic exercise on migraine triggers profile. Objective: To evaluate the effects of a 12-week aerobic exercise intervention on migraine triggers profile. Methods: We conducted a secondary, post hoc analysis of a randomized, controlled clinical trial. Triggers were recorded in a paper-based headache diary with a formal list including 8 common migraine triggers. Results: Twenty-five patients concluded the protocol and were analysed (exercise: n = 12; waitlist: n = 13). In the whole cohort, the most common triggers were stress/irritability (60 %), sleep deprivation (60 %), fasting (28 %), and foods (28 %). Most patients (52 %) had ³ 3 triggers. The exercise group showed a higher baseline proportion of patients with ³ 3 triggers (69 %) compared to waitlist group (25 %) (p = 0.041). After intervention period, there was no difference in the proportion of patients with ³ 3 triggers between waitlist (16.6 %) and exercise (30 %) groups (p = 0.502). The exercise group showed greater numeric reductions (from group’s sum) than waitlist group for triggers stress/irritability (-14 vs -9), fatigue (-12 vs -6), and menstruation (-9 vs -5). This seemed to reflect the reduced number of attacks in the exercise group [mean (CI95 %): -2.5 (-3.7, -1), p = 0.002] vs waitlist [0.9 (2.4, -0.8), p = 0.341]. Conclusion: Tracking migraine triggers during exercise interventions may help to unravel specific clinical effects of regular exercise. Trial registration: #NCT01972607. 

Keywords: Physical Activity, Exercise, Stress, Treatment, Triggers.

 

RESUMO

Embora o exercício aeróbico seja recomendado no tratamento da migrânea, nenhum estudo seu efeito no padrão de fatores desencadeantes das crises, os chamados “gatilhos”. O objetivo desse estudo foi avaliar se um programa de exercícios aeróbicos de 12 semanas afeta o perfil de gatilhos reportados pelos pacientes. Foi realizada uma análise secundária post hoc de um estudo controlado e randomizado. Os gatilhos foram registrados em diário da dor impresso contendo uma lista de 8 gatilhos frequentemente reportados na literatura. Vinte e cinco participantes concluíram o protocolo e foram analizados. Na amostra total, os gatilhos mais comuns foram estresse/irritabilidade (60%), privação do sono (60 %), jejum (28 %) e alimentos (28 %). A maioria dos pacientes (52 %) reportaram ³ 3 gatilhos. O grupo exercício mostrou maior proporção de pacientes com ³ 3 gatilhos (69 %) no período pré intervenção em comparação com o grupo controle (25 %) (p = 0.041). Após intervenção, essa diferença não foi observada (exercício = 30 % vs controle = 16.6, p = 502). O grupo exercício mostrou maior redução numérica (dados de soma dos gatilhos por grupo) em comparação com o grupo controle para os gatilhos estresse/ irritabilidade (-14 vs -9), fadiga (-12 vs -6) e menstruação (-9 vs -5). Esse efeito refletiu redução no número dos ataques no grupo exercício [média (IC 95 %):-2.5 (-3.7, -1), p = 0.002] vs grupo controle [0.9 (2.4, -0.8), p = 0.341]. O registro no padrão de gatilhos durante intervenções com exercícios pode auxiliar no rastreio de efeitos clínicos específicos ainda não estudados. Registro do estudo clínico: NCT01972607.

Descritores: Atividade Física, Exercício Físico, Migrânea, Fatores Desencadeantes, Estresse.

 

INTRODUCTION

     Growing body of evidence has strengthened the therapeutic benefits of regular physical activity for the management of migraine1. In particular, aerobic exercise performed at moderate intensity and practiced 3 times per week is accounted for reducing around 30-40 % the number of migraine attacks/days with migraine2–4), with therapeutic effects comparable to preventive medication5,6. Other health outcomes such as perceived stress, mood, and well-being may also improve by adopting aerobic exercise as an adjunct treatment for migraine2,7,8. However, there are still other unexplored effects of aerobic exercise on clinical aspects of migraine, such as the triggers profile of patients.

     Many patients perceive a myriad of internal or external stimuli as precipitants of migraine attacks, the so-called triggers9–13. A recent meta-analysis showed that nearly 90% of headache patients report at least one consistent trigger9. The most common triggers reported by patients include stress, sleep deprivation, fasting, certain foods, menstruation, to name a few9. While physical exercise is also considered a trigger by around 20-40 % of patients14,15, many evidences from clinical and epidemiological studies strengthen the recommendation of regular aerobic exercise, and the current understanding is that the protective effect outweighs possible harmful triggered during exercise1,16. In fact, exercise imposes a challenge to homeostasis at molecular and physiological levels in several neurobehavioral and physiological processes, it could interact with mechanisms thought to be involved in migraine triggers, such as sleep, stress response, hydration, hypoglycaemia, and so forth to either worse/precipitate the attacks or prevent them(1,17).

     In this sense, exploring the patient´s trigger pattern while engaging in an exercise training program may have clinical and behavioural implications, and even affect exercise prescription recommendation for this population. Therefore, it is necessary to understand better the relationship between aerobic exercise and migraine under the perspective of triggers factors. To our knowledge, no study has yet evaluated the response of regular aerobic exercise on the triggers’ profile of migraine patients. Thus, the scope of this study was to evaluate the trigger profile of a migraine patient cohort following a 12-week aerobic exercise program. Because there is inter-person variability for triggers, we did not set any a priori hypothesis. We rather conducted an exploratory data analysis, then provided contextual interpretation based on current literature.

 

METHODS

 

Study Design

     This study consists of a secondary, post hoc, per- protocol analysis of an open-label, randomized controlled clinical trial aiming to assess clinical outcomes in migraine patients following a 12-week aerobic exercise program(2).

     We retrospectively analysed the triggers recorded in the headache diary of patients.

     The study protocol was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Sao Paulo Federal University, and have therefore been performed in accordance with the ethical standards laid down in the 1964 Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments. All participants gave their informed consent prior to their inclusion in the study. The trial has been registered in the National Institute of Health (www.ClinicalTrials.gov) under #NCT01972607. The study complies with the CONSORT’s Statement on data reporting for non-pharmacological trials(18).

 

Participants

     Participants were recruited and screened in the Neurology Department of the Sao Paulo Federal University. The inclusion criteria were: subjects of both sexes, between 18 and 65  years,  physically  inactive  the previous 12 months (defined as £ 1 day/week of leisure-time physical activity). Exclusion criteria were: patients taking any prescribed medication or dietary supplements; practicing mind-body activities (e.g., yoga, tai chi, etc.); pregnancy; clinical history of cardiovascular, pulmonary, metabolic, rheumatic, musculoskeletal, psychiatric, or other neurological disease. All participants had a neurological and cardiological examination before inclusion in study.

 

Migraine Triggers Assessment

     Clinical data were retrieved from paper-based headache diary. Besides the data on migraine frequency, the diary had a formal list including eight common migraine triggers: “stress/irritability”, “sleep deprivation”, “oversleep”, “fasting”, “foods”, “odours”, “photic stimuli”, “alcohol”, and “other” for non-listed factors. If there were no identifiable triggers, patients were instructed to let the option for description blank.

 

Statistical Analyses

     Descriptive statistics and comparison between groups for participants’ characteristics were calculated by independent t-test (normal distribution assumed). Within-group differences for migraine frequency (continuous variable) pre-post intervention were computed by paired t-test. These data are shown as mean and 95 % confidence interval. For triggers/clinical variables analyses, the pre- and post-intervention periods were set as the 4 weeks prior the 12-week intervention period and the last 4 weeks of this intervention period, respectively.

     Descriptive statistics for trigger profile are expressed as either group or whole cohort percentage, or group’s sum. Comparisons in the proportion of triggers/patient pre and post intervention were calculated by two-sided Exact Fisher’s test. Data were computed in the SPSS software (IBM, Version 19.0, Chicago, IL). A p value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

 

RESULTS

     Twenty-five participants were per-protocol analysed. Table 1 shows participants clinical and anthropometrical characteristics. In the whole cohort, 92 % of patients (23 out of 25 patients) reported at least one trigger during the intervention period. The most common triggers were stress/irritability (15/25 patients, or 60%), sleep deprivation (15/25 patients, or 60%), fasting (7/25 patients, or 28 %), food (7/25 patients, or 28 %), and odours (5/25 patients, or 20%). The groups’ trigger profile are shown in the Figure 1. Most patients (13/25, or 52%) ascribed ³ 3 triggers to their attacks in the baseline period.

 

https://headachemedicine.com.br/images/488-1.png

     The exercise group showed a higher baseline proportion of patients with ³ 3 triggers (69 %) compared to waitlist group (25 %) (p = 0.041) (Figure 2). After intervention period, the exercise group showed reduced migraine attack frequency compared to waitlist group [mean (CI 95 %): exercise = -2.5 (-3.7, -1), p = 0.002 vs waitlist = 0.9 (2.4, -0.8), p = 0.341], while there was no difference in the proportion of patients with ³ 3 triggers between waitlist (16.6 %) and exercise (30 %) groups (p = 0.502) (Figure 2). The exercise group showed greater numeric reductions (i.e., “Δ” values computed from group’s sum) than waitlist group for the triggers stress/irritability (-14   vs -9), fatigue (-12 vs -6), and menstruation (-9 vs -5)(Figure 3).

     Figure 4 illustrates the flow of migraine triggers for each group across time from baseline to post intervention period. Triggers that were not reported by patients in any period of intervention were designated “no trigger”.

 

DISCUSSION

     To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate the triggers profile of migraine patients following exercise training. In this secondary analysis, we tracked back the triggers’ profile of a migraine patient cohort enrolled in a randomized control trial testing the efficacy of aerobic exercise training for migraine prevention. We intended to identify possible changes in the pattern of trigger profile following the aerobic exercise training protocol.

https://headachemedicine.com.br/images/488-1.png

Figure 1. Trigger profile observed in waitlist and exercise groups.

https://headachemedicine.com.br/images/481-2.png

Figure 2. Triggger profile before and after exercice.

     We confirmed previous studies showing a high percentage of patients reporting at least one trigger (over 90 %)9, as well as we replicated the data showing perceive stress, sleep deprivation, and fasting (skipping meals) as the most common triggers9–13. We found that the higher proportion of patients with ³ 3 triggers in the exercise group compared to waitlist group at baseline equalized the waitlist group after intervention period (Figure 2), probably reflecting the reduction in the number of migraine attacks across time with exercise training. This also seemed to be the case regarding the greater numeric reduction for most triggers in the exercise group (Figure 3). Moreover, this larger numeric reduction for some triggers in the exercise group could be due to a greater sample size in this group.

     While regular aerobic exercise may reduce migraine frequency1,3, between 1/4 and 1/3 of migraine patients report physical exercise as a consistent trigger14,15. Surprisingly, there was no reported physical exercise- triggered attack in this study. Some explanations to this finding may be the fact that all participants were willing to participate in an exercise program, the exercise intensity was gradually increased up to the level prescribed (moderate intensity around 70% of the age-predicted maximum heart rate) based on cardiorespiratory parameters, and all exercise sessions were supervised.

https://headachemedicine.com.br/images/481-3.png

Figure 3. Change in common migraine triggers after intervention period.

https://headachemedicine.com.br/images/481-4.png

Figure 4. Flow of migraine triggers for each group across time from baseline to post intervention period.

     It is relevant to understand the relation of triggers with physical exercise, since there is no specific exercise prescription recommendation for migraine patients with regard to their personal trigger profile, or whether or not the surge of new popular exercise modalities could be deleterious for the migraine patient. For example, new popular exercise modalities that rapidly gain adepts worldwide  such  as  high  intensity  interval  training19  or training in a fasted state20, can be challenging for a migraine patient and is impractical to be recommended. On the other hand, in face of positive metabolic and cardiovascular benefit of these exercise  modalities, one could question whether a progressive introduction of such exercise  types would benefit clinical aspects of migraine, including the trigger pattern. Such trigger  analysis, in clinical practice, could help patients to detect either positive or potentially harmful effects of regular physical activity interacting with subjective triggers. In the future, further studies could establish specific exercise prescription recommendations for this population.

     Although the data here do not allow us to draw conclusion for specific effects of exercise training on the pattern of migraine triggers, regular aerobic exercise training mediates several neurdocrine, neuroimmune, and neuromodulatory processes, which could be accounted for the greater reduction in triggers such as stress/irritability, sleep deprivation, menstruation, neck pain, and fatigue in the intervention group. For example, regular exercise is thought to promote anti-inflammatory  effects21, regulate the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis mediating habituation of stress response22–24, which are akin with the recent evidence of exercise-mediate anxiolysis and lower pro-inflammatory cytokines in migraine women7. Also, aerobic exercise may improve sleep quality, and therefore could prevent sleep deprivation-triggered attacks, by changing melatonin production25,26, which in its turn represent a endogenous molecule thought to play a role in the pathomechanisms of migraine disorders27. A recent study showed that aerobic exercise helped to reduce neck pain in a particular subpopulation of patients presenting with both migraine and tension-type headaches28. Less attacks due to fatigue could reflect improvement in oxidative energy metabolism following exercise training through changes in mitochondrial function, which has been also linked to migraine pathophysiology29,30.

     There was a large difference in non-identifiable triggers between groups (20 attacks). It is likely that interference from attention and care delivered by researchers to the exercise group during the exercise sessions may have rendered participants more aware of their triggers by speaking with researchers about their personal clinical features.

 

Limitations and Strengths

     There are limitations in this study, which hamper one to generalise our findings. The study is comprised of a small sample of patients interested in adopting aerobic exercise training as a non-pharmacological approach to manage their migraine. This constitute selection bias and, thus, this sample do not represent the general migraine population. Furthermore, this is a secondary, per-protocol analysis, which means that the analyses were designed after randomization. The strengths of this study lie on the trigger data collected through paper-based diary throughout the study period, and a supervised exercise program design.

     Taking into account multiple neurophysiological and biochemical processes affected by physical exercise, and possible relation to migraine triggers mechanisms, further studies are needed to elucidate particular clinical responses of aerobic exercise training in a more representative sample.

 

CONCLUSIONS

     The preventive effect of regular aerobic exercise may reflect on the triggers pattern of patients. Mostly by reducing the number of triggers, and the more frequent ones. Tracking the patient triggers profile during exercise training interventions may unravel specific clinical data, and further advance the understanding of the relationship between exercise and migraine. The implications on exercise prescription should be further explored in the future.

     Acknowledgements: The authors are grateful to the whole staff of the Centre for Studies on Exercise Psychobiology and to all patients.

 

REFERENCES

  1. Amin FM, Aristeidou S, Baraldi C, Czapinska-Ciepiela EK, Ariadni DD, di Lenola D, et al. The association between migraine and physical exercise. The journal of headache and pain [Internet]. 2018;19(1):83.
  2. Oliveira AB, Ribeiro RT, Mello MT, Tufik S, Peres MFP. Anandamide Is Related to Clinical and Cardiorespiratory Benefits of Aerobic Exercise Training in Migraine  Patients: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research. 2019 Feb 28;can.2018.0057.
  3. Lemmens J, de Pauw J, van Soom T, Michiels S, Versijpt   J, van Breda E, et al. The effect of aerobic exercise on the number of migraine days, duration and pain intensity in migraine: A systematic literature review and meta-analysis. Journal of Headache and Pain. 2019;20(16):1–9.
  4. Irby MB, Bond DS, Lipton RB, Nicklas B, Houle TT, Penzien DB. Aerobic Exercise for Reducing Migraine Burden: Mechanisms, Markers, and Models of Change Processes. Headache. 2016;56(2):357–69.
  5. Santiago MDS, Carvalho D de S, Gabbai AA, Pinto MMP, Moutran ARC, Villa TR. Amitriptyline and aerobic exercise or amitriptyline alone in the  treatment  of chronic  migraine: a randomized comparative study. Arquivos de Neuro- Psiquiatria [Internet]. 2014;72(11):851–5.
  6. Varkey E, Cider A, Carlsson J, Linde M. Exercise as migraine prophylaxis: a randomized study using relaxation and topiramate as controls. Cephalalgia: an international journal of headache. 2011 Oct;31(14):1428–38.
  7. Oliveira AB, Bachi ALL, Ribeiro RT, Mello MT, Vaisberg M, Peres MFP. Exercise-Induced Change in Plasma IL-12p70 Is Linked to Migraine Prevention and Anxiolytic Effects in Treatment-Naïve Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial. NeuroImmunoModulation. 2017;24(6):293–299.
  8. Darabaneanu S, Overath CH, Rubin D, Lüthje S, Sye W, Niederberger U, et al. Aerobic exercise as a therapy option for migraine: a pilot study. International journal of sports medicine. 2011 Jun;32(6):455–60.
  9. Pellegrino ABW, Davis-Martin RE, Houle TT, Turner DP, Smitherman TA. Perceived triggers of primary headache disorders: A meta-analysis. Cephalalgia [Internet]. 2017;38(6):1188–98.
  10. Fukui P, Gonsalves T, Strabelli C, Lucchino N, Matos F, Santos J, et al. Trigger factors in migraine patients. Arquivos de neuro-psiquiatria. 2008 Jul;66(3-A):494–9.
  11. Hauge AW, Kirchmann M, Olesen J. Characterization of consistent triggers of migraine with aura. Cephalalgia. 2010;31(4):416–38.
  12. Wöber C, Holzhammer J, Zeitlhofer J et al. Trigger factors of migraine and tension-type headache: experience and knowledge of the patients. The journal of headache and pain. 2006 Sep;7(4):188–95.
  13. Peris F, Donoghue S, Torres F, Mian A, Wober C. Towards improved migraine management: Determining potential trigger factors in individual patients. Cephalalgia [Internet]. 2017;37(5):452–63
  14. Koppen H, van Veldhoven PLJ. Migraineurs with exercise- triggered attacks have a distinct migraine. The journal of headache and pain. 2013;14:99.
  15. Kelman L. The triggers or precipitants of the acute migraine attack. Cephalalgia: an international journal of headache. 2007 May;27(5):394–402.
  16. Lippi G, Mattiuzzi C, Sanchis-Gomar F. Physical exercise and migraine: for or against? Annals of Translational Medicine. 2018;6(10):181–181.
  17. Oliveira AB, Bachi ALL, Ribeiro RT, Mello MT, Tufik S, Peres MFP. Unbalanced plasma TNF-α and IL-12/IL-10 profile in women with migraine is associated with psychological and physiological outcomes. Journal of Neuroimmunology. 2017;313:138–44.
  18. Boutron I, Moher D, Altman DG et al. Extending the CONSORT Statement to Randomized Trials of Nonpharmacologic Treatment: Explanation and Elaboration. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2008;148:295–309.
  19. Jr RBB, Duncan MJ, Dalbo VJ, Tucker PS, Fenning AS. Effects of high-intensity interval training on cardiometabolic health: a systematic review and meta-analysis of intervention studies. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2017;51(6):494–503.
  20. Aird TP, Davies RW, Carson BP. Effects of fasted vs fed- state exercise on performance and exercise metabolism: A systematic review and meta- analysis. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports. 2018;28:1476–93.
  21. Pedersen BK. Anti-inflammatory effects of exercise: role in diabetes and cardiovascular disease. European Journal of Clinical Investigation. 2017;47(8):600–11.
  22. Zschucke E, Renneberg B, Dimeo F et al. The stress-buffering effect of acute exercise: Evidence for HPA axis negative feedback. Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2015;51:414–25.
  23. Greenwood BN, Fleshner M. Exercise, Learned Helplessness, and the Stress-Resistant Brain. NeuroMolecular Medicine [Internet]. 2008;10(2):81–98.
  24. Dhabhar FS. Effects of stress on immune function: the good, the bad, and the beautiful. Immunologic Research. 2014;58:193–210.
  25. Knight J a, Thompson S, Raboud JM, Hoffman BR. Light and exercise and melatonin production in women. American journal of epidemiology [Internet]. 2005 Dec  1  [cited  2014 Mar 29];162(11):1114–22.
  26. Atkinson G, Edwards B, Reilly T, Waterhouse  J.  Exercise as a synchroniser of human circadian rhythms: an update and discussion of the methodological problems. European journal of applied physiology [Internet]. 2007;99(4):331–41
  27. Peres MF, Valença MM, Amaral FG, Cipolla-Neto J. Current understanding of pineal gland structure and function in headache. Cephalalgia. 2019;0(0):1–10.
  28. Krøll LS, Hammarlund CS, Linde M, Gard G, Jensen RH. The effects of aerobic exercise for persons with migraine and co- existing tension-type headache and neck pain. A randomized, controlled, clinical trial. Cephalalgia. 2018;0(0):1–12.
  29. Granata C, Jamnick NA, Bishop DJ. Correction to: Principles of Exercise Prescription, and How They Influence Exercise- Induced Changes of Transcription Factors and Other Regulators of Mitochondrial Biogenesis (Sports Medicine, (2018), 48,   7,   (1541-1559),   10.1007/s40279-018-0894-4). Sports Medicine. 2018;48(8):1991.
  30. Guo S, Esserlind AL, Andersson Z, Frederiksen AL, Olesen J, Vissing J, et al. Prevalence of migraine in persons with the 3243A>G mutation in mitochondrial DNA. European Journal of Neurology. 2016;23(1):175–81.